game-ism.com

game-ism.com header image 4

Entries Tagged as 'critique'

Creed Critique: Glitch vs. Pretty

March 2nd, 2008 · 5 Comments

One of the things I’m noticing in my playthrough of Assassin’s Creed (although they aren’t the only ones doing this) that is bugging me a lot lately is this mis-placed idea that the character animations always have to “line up” with what he’s really doing in the world.  Somehow “next-gen” has come to mean “more [...]

[Read more →]

Tags: combat · critique · design · uncategorized

PGR4 vs. Google Streetview: Vegas Edition

February 7th, 2008 · 1 Comment

For quite a few years I’ve been impressed with how amazing the Project Gotham’s team is at rendering reality, and while playing PGR4 the other week, I saw that the only two U.S. cities represented were Vegas and NYC. At first I was a bit bummed because I honestly don’t have any real authority [...]

[Read more →]

Tags: critique

When Good Tech Goes Wrong

January 14th, 2008 · 1 Comment

But the tanks? A serious disappointment. They were obviously nothing more than armored pickup trucks with a turret attached to them, as far as the code was concerned. They didn’t do anything that an actual tank could do. Hell, sometimes, they couldn’t even drive in reverse uphill, and I won’t even get into the “friendly” AI driving worse than a NY cabbie. Still worse, the optics on them were non-existent. I.E. they had none. A current day Abrams tank can accurately hit a target two miles away. Crysis takes place, what, ten years in the future and I can’t get a set of optics on the thing even half as good as a sniper rifle? Hell, I’ll even take the assault scope optics here. Just give me some optics. But none? Completely inexcusable. On foot I’ve got my choice of two different scopes and a pair of smart binoculars with a laser/shotgun microphone. Am I to believe there was no room for a pair of binoculars on this tank?

[Read more →]

Tags: combat · critique · nitpicking

The Jedi Multiplayer Exception*

January 9th, 2008 · 5 Comments

Awhile back I mentioned that my number one rule in game design is: Gameplay is King. It will always be king. There is nothing that should ever trump it. Not the art, not the license, nothing.
Except for one thing: Jedi.
It goes without saying that Jedi are extremely popular in geek/nerdlore/culture. [...]

[Read more →]

Tags: combat · critique · multiplayer

Naruto: Are Two Buttons Enough?

January 7th, 2008 · No Comments

Was playing some Naruto:  Rise of the Ninja at work today, and did some head-to-head vs. mode combat.  It turns out it was good research/competitive analysis, because Naruto only uses two attack buttons, and it seems that’s the direction a lot of modern titles are heading in for combat as well.  The idea is that [...]

[Read more →]

Tags: combat · critique · user interface

Critiquing CoD4: My War, Let Me Show You It.

December 23rd, 2007 · No Comments

Awhile back Clint over at ClickNothing did a great critique of Bioshock, and it got me thinking that designers should be doing this regularly. As an industry, we have countless outlets for reviews of games; a consumer level media wrap-up of a “buy it or not” standard. But what we don’t have is a professional [...]

[Read more →]

Tags: combat · critique